Potato investigation
For salt concentration and potato mass change, control potato variety, cylinder size, solution volume, temperature and exposure time. Record exact amounts and measurement steps so another group can repeat them.
Year 8 Science • Science inquiry • Planning and conducting • AC9S8I02
A reproducible investigation records enough detail for another investigator to repeat the method and obtain comparable evidence safely and responsibly.
Recall independent, dependent and controlled variables, and the difference between an investigable question and a testable hypothesis.
Use the chain question → variables → method → assumptions → risk/ethics/heritage checks → repeatable evidence. Reproducible does not mean every result is identical; comparable results may still vary naturally.
Record materials, quantities, equipment, sequence, timing, units and conditions. Changing more than one relevant factor creates alternative explanations.
An analogous model represents selected features. State what it represents and omits: dialysis tubing, a shake table and a baking-soda volcano are useful only within their assumptions.
A hazard can cause harm; risk combines likelihood and consequence. Ethical planning includes consent, privacy, voluntary participation and appropriate use of biological or secondary data. Fieldwork must respect heritage sites, artefacts and protocols on Country/Place.
For salt concentration and potato mass change, control potato variety, cylinder size, solution volume, temperature and exposure time. Record exact amounts and measurement steps so another group can repeat them.
Dialysis tubing can model selective movement but not every living-membrane process. A shake table represents some earthquake motion; a baking-soda volcano represents pressure release but not magma chemistry or tectonics.
For a splash hazard, use eye protection, a safer concentration and a stable work area. A useful control lowers risk without removing the scientific purpose.
Before work near heritage sites or artefacts, seek permissions and cultural guidance. Prefer non-destructive methods when the question can be answered without collecting or disturbing material.
A field investigation could answer its question by removing rock samples from a culturally significant site or by using remote imaging. Compare the scientific evidence, risk and cultural responsibilities of both methods.
Exit ticket: Why can a scientifically useful method still be unacceptable?
Require exact method language and separate the scientific method check from the risk, ethics and heritage check.
Ask whether another person could repeat the method exactly and what permissions or protections would be needed.
Australian Curriculum v9.0 — AC9S8I02: plan and conduct reproducible investigations to answer questions and test hypotheses, including variables, assumptions, risks, ethics and heritage considerations on Country/Place.
Victorian Curriculum F–10 Version 2.0 — Levels 7–8, VC2S8I02: Exact.
NSW Science 7–10 Syllabus (2023) — Stage 4, SC4-WS-03; SC4-WS-04: Exact — the NSW Working Scientifically outcomes directly align with the core inquiry process.
| Framework | Level/Stage | Relationship | Mapping |
|---|---|---|---|
| Australian Curriculum | Year 8 | Canonical | AC9S8I02 |
| Victoria V2.0 | Levels 7–8 | Exact | VC2S8I02 |
| NSW 2023 | Stage 4 | Exact | SC4-WS-03; SC4-WS-04 |
The SkillrHub lesson remains the primary learning resource. This optional video reinforces the explanation; you can complete the lesson and practice without watching.
Before you watch:
Amoeba Sisters — Identify variables and controls so that an investigation can test a question meaningfully.
As you watch: Which conditions must be kept consistent to make a comparison interpretable?
Load video player Loads YouTube in this lesson. See the video notice below.
Try it: Draft a paper-helicopter investigation plan. State the changed, measured and controlled variables, repeat trials and instructions another group could reproduce. Identify relevant safety checks.
Video unavailable, inaccurate or unsuitable for this year? Report a video problem to SkillrHub by email. You can continue with the written lesson and practice resources.
Videos are curated from trusted independent educational creators and played through YouTube. Rights remain with their respective owners. Inclusion does not imply that a creator or YouTube endorses SkillrHub.
YouTube’s terms and privacy policy apply to its player. Advertising, recommendations and external links may appear, and videos may change or become unavailable. SkillrHub’s written lessons and practice resources remain available separately.
To report a content, suitability or rights concern, email skillrhublearning@gmail.com with the lesson code and video link. Please do not include personal student information.
Mapped skill: plan and conduct reproducible investigations to answer questions and test hypotheses, including identifying variables and assumptions and, as appropriate, recognising and managing risks, considering ethical issues and recognising key considerations regarding heritage sites and artefacts on Country/Place
These references identify matching or closely related learning. Curriculum sequence, terminology and depth vary, so teachers should use the mapped skill and lesson difficulty to confirm suitability.
| Region | Curriculum framework | Closest level or code |
|---|---|---|
| Australia | Australian Curriculum v9.0 | AC9S8I02 · Year 8 |
| Victoria | Victorian Curriculum F–10 Version 2.0 — Science | VC2S8I02 · Levels 7–8 |
| New South Wales | NSW Science 7–10 Syllabus (2023) | SC4-WS-03 + SC4-WS-04 · Stage 4 |
| United States (USA) | Next Generation Science Standards (NGSS) | Middle School (Grades 6–8) |
| Canada (Ontario) | Ontario Curriculum — Science | Grade 8 |
| United Kingdom (England) | National Curriculum in England — Science | Year 9, Key Stage 3 |
| India | NCERT / CBSE — Science | Class 8 |
Australian Curriculum v9.0 is the canonical source for this SkillrHub lesson. Victoria and NSW entries name the closest published state codes or outcomes; international entries are planning references rather than claims of identical curricula.
Help improve SkillrHub
Ask about this lesson, suggest an improvement or report an error. Facebook opens only when you choose an option below.
Topic reference: AC9S8I02 — Plan and Conduct Reproducible Investigations — AC9S8I02
Privacy: Please don’t share personal student or school information. Younger students should ask a parent, guardian or teacher to post on their behalf.