AC9E10LA02 • Year 10 English

Understand that language used to evaluate, implicitly or explicitly reveals an individual's values

Use evidence to explain how understand that language used to evaluate, implicitly or explicitly reveals an individual's values shapes meaning.

Learning goals

Learning intention

We are learning to explain how deliberate language and text choices shape meaning for an audience or reader.

Australian Curriculum target: understand that language used to evaluate, implicitly or explicitly reveals an individual's values

Success criteria

  • Identify a precise language or text choice.
  • Use the surrounding context as evidence.
  • Explain the effect on audience, relationship, purpose or reader response.
  • Transfer the explanation to a new example.
Prerequisite knowledge

Before this lesson

  • Read a short text closely.
  • Locate a phrase, structural choice or visual/text feature.
  • Use a complete sentence to explain an effect.
Key concept

Teach the core concept

In this topic, students move from naming a feature to explaining how the feature works in context.

  • understand that language used to evaluate, implicitly or explicitly reveals an individual's values
  • choice → context → effect reasoning

Teacher model: Read a short example, underline one exact choice, identify who it is for, then explain what the choice makes the audience notice, feel, believe or question.

Worked examples

Worked examples

Choice → context → effect

Teacher model: Do not stop at naming a technique. Show the evidence, place it in context and explain the effect.

  1. Choice: Identify the exact word, structure or text feature connected to understand that language used to evaluate, implicitly or explicitly reveals an individual's values.
  2. Context: Explain who is speaking or writing, for whom, and what the text is doing.
  3. Effect: Explain how the choice shapes meaning, relationship, purpose or reader response.

E1: Connect word choice to meaning and audience effect

A writer or speaker can use word choice to shape identifying explicit expressions of values when evaluating and influence how an audience understands the text.

Teacher move: Highlight the exact wording that shows word choice, then connect it to identifying explicit expressions of values when evaluating.

Ask: Which choice is evidence, and what effect does it create for the audience?

E2: Connect audience to meaning and audience effect

A writer or speaker can use audience to shape identifying subtle or implied values communicated through language and influence how an audience understands the text.

Teacher move: Highlight the exact wording that shows audience, then connect it to identifying subtle or implied values communicated through language.

Ask: Which choice is evidence, and what effect does it create for the audience?

One word, different effect

Show two short versions of the same message. Students underline the changed choice and predict the audience effect.

Share: Pairs share the choice before the interpretation.

Questions and answers

Important questions and answers

  1. Q1: What exact language or text choice helps show connect word choice to meaning and audience effect? A: Use a precise piece of evidence, explain its context, then link it to audience or reader effect.
  2. Q2: What exact language or text choice helps show connect audience to meaning and audience effect? A: Use a precise piece of evidence, explain its context, then link it to audience or reader effect.
  3. Q: Why is context important? A: The same choice can create a different effect when the audience, speaker, purpose or text type changes.
Common misconceptions

Common misconceptions

  • A feature name is enough to prove an interpretation.: Use the frame: ‘The choice ___ suggests/positions ___ because ___.’
  • Effect means whether the student personally likes the text.: Replace preference with an audience effect supported by the exact wording or structure.

Do not overteach

  • Do not require university-level terminology or theory.
  • Do not treat one interpretation as valid without evidence.
  • Do not replace close reading with plot summary or personal preference.
Guided practice

Guided practice

Step 1: Notice the exact choice

Highlight one phrase, structure or image.

Students: Names what the text does.

Step 2: Compare alternatives

Place two versions side by side.

Students: Identifies what changes.

Step 3: Explain the effect

Model choice → context → effect.

Students: Builds a complete analytical sentence.

Step 4: Transfer to a new example

Remove the worked example.

Students: Applies the frame independently.

Check: Explain how one deliberate choice shapes meaning in understand that language used to evaluate, implicitly or explicitly reveals an individual's values.

Independent practice

Independent practice

  1. Choose a short unseen text or extract.
  2. Highlight one deliberate language, structure or visual choice.
  3. Write one claim that links the choice to audience, purpose, relationship or reader response.
  4. Revise the sentence so it includes evidence, context and effect.
Reasoning and interpretation

Reasoning challenge

Explain how one deliberate choice shapes meaning in understand that language used to evaluate, implicitly or explicitly reveals an individual's values.

Reasoning frame: The choice ___ matters because in this context it positions the audience to ___.

Practice and review

Assessment-style practice

  1. Analyse one exact word or phrase and explain how it positions the audience.
  2. Compare two versions of the same idea and evaluate which is more effective.
  3. Write a short analytical paragraph using claim, evidence and effect.

Review hint: A full-mark answer names the choice, quotes or describes evidence accurately, explains context, and links the effect to meaning.

Check understanding

Mastery check

Explain how one deliberate choice shapes meaning in understand that language used to evaluate, implicitly or explicitly reveals an individual's values.

Strong response: The response identifies a precise language or text choice, places it in context and explains its effect on audience, relationship, purpose or reader response.

Teacher and parent/carer guidance

Support, core and extend

Support

Use two short versions, colour-code choice and effect, and provide the sentence frame ‘The choice ___ makes the audience ___ because ___.’

Keep the concept: Keeps the same choice → effect reasoning with reduced text load.

Core

Annotate an extract and write a choice–context–effect explanation.

Keep the concept: Directly assesses the listed English concept.

Extend

Compare two audiences or mediums and evaluate which wording is more effective, citing evidence.

Keep the concept: Deepens evaluation without requiring later-year theory.

At home: Ask students to explain how one wording choice changes the way a reader responds, rather than only naming the technique.

Curriculum alignment

Curriculum coverage and elaborations

The content description is the required target. Elaborations are examples and contexts that support the same learning goal.

  • E1: identifying explicit expressions of values when evaluating
  • E2: identifying subtle or implied values communicated through language; for example, using a term such as “teenager” to refer to an individual rather than using a specific name

International curriculum mapping

RegionEnglish / ELA curriculumClosest alignment
AustraliaAustralian Curriculum v9.0AC9E10LA02 — understand that language used to evaluate, implicitly or explicitly reveals an individual's values
VictoriaVictorian Curriculum F–10 Version 2.0 EnglishLevel 10 English — closest Language, Literature or Literacy alignment; verify local outcome wording for assessment.
NSWEnglish K–10 Syllabus (2022)Stage 5 — closest NSW English outcome alignment; use as a planning comparison rather than a one-to-one code conversion.
United StatesCommon Core State Standards for ELA/LiteracyGrade 10 broad ELA alignment across reading, writing, speaking/listening or language depending on the outcome focus.
EnglandNational curriculum in England: EnglishKey Stage 4 — closest reading, writing, spoken-language, grammar or literary-analysis programme-of-study alignment.
New ZealandThe New Zealand Curriculum – English Years 0–10Phase 4 (Years 9–10) — closest oral language, reading/writing, Text Studies or Language Studies alignment.
Official curriculum references
Practice and teaching resources

Practice and teaching resources

🎥 Optional Video Lesson

The SkillrHub lesson remains the primary learning resource. This optional video reinforces the explanation; you can complete the lesson and practice without watching.

Back to the lesson

Before you watch:

  • Pause after each worked example.
  • Try the examples yourself.
  • Return to the SkillrHub lesson before continuing.
Recommended: How to use rhetoric to get what you want - Camille A. Langston

TED-Ed — Identifying appeals to credibility, reason and emotion in evaluative language.

As you watch: What does an emotional appeal suggest about the values an audience is expected to share?

Load video player Loads YouTube in this lesson. See the video notice below.

Try it: Annotate a persuasive paragraph: identify an appeal, the value it assumes and whether that value is explicit or implied.

Video unavailable, inaccurate or unsuitable for this year? Report a video problem to SkillrHub by email. You can continue with the written lesson and practice resources.

About these videos

Videos are curated from trusted independent educational creators and played through YouTube. Rights remain with their respective owners. Inclusion does not imply that a creator or YouTube endorses SkillrHub.

YouTube’s terms and privacy policy apply to its player. Advertising, recommendations and external links may appear, and videos may change or become unavailable. SkillrHub’s written lessons and practice resources remain available separately.

To report a content, suitability or rights concern, email skillrhublearning@gmail.com with the lesson code and video link. Please do not include personal student information.

Curriculum equivalents: Victoria, NSW and international

Curriculum equivalents for That language used to evaluate, implicitly or explicitly reveals an...

Mapped skill: understand that language used to evaluate, implicitly or explicitly reveals an individual's values

These references identify matching or closely related learning. Curriculum sequence, terminology and depth vary, so teachers should use the mapped skill and lesson difficulty to confirm suitability.

RegionCurriculum frameworkClosest level or code
AustraliaAustralian Curriculum v9.0AC9E10LA02 · Year 10
VictoriaVictorian Curriculum F–10 Version 2.0 — EnglishVC2E10LA02 · Level 10
New South WalesNSW English K–10 Syllabus (2022)EN5-URB-01 · Stage 5
United States (USA)Common Core State Standards for English Language ArtsGrades 9–10 band
Canada (Ontario)Ontario Curriculum — EnglishGrade 10
United Kingdom (England)National Curriculum in England — EnglishYear 11, Key Stage 4
IndiaNCERT / CBSE — EnglishClass 10

Australian Curriculum v9.0 is the canonical source for this SkillrHub lesson. Victoria and NSW entries name the closest published state codes or outcomes; international entries are planning references rather than claims of identical curricula.

Help improve SkillrHub

Questions or feedback?

Ask about this lesson, suggest an improvement or report an error. Facebook opens only when you choose an option below.

Topic reference: AC9E10LA02 — Understand that language used to evaluate, implicitly or explicitly reveals an individual's values

💬 Ask a question 💡 Suggest an improvement ⚠️ Report an error

Privacy: Please don’t share personal student or school information. Younger students should ask a parent, guardian or teacher to post on their behalf.

Worked example and reasoning checks

Infer values from evaluative language

Explain what an evaluation reveals about a speaker's priorities, using precise evidence.

Worked example

Two fictional reviewers describe the same library redesign: ‘Every metre now earns its keep’ and ‘The quiet corners have been sacrificed’. What does each value?

  1. The first uses ‘earns its keep’ to praise productive use of space, suggesting efficiency or utility is valued.
  2. The second uses ‘sacrificed’ to frame lost quiet spaces as a significant cost, suggesting privacy or contemplative reading is valued.
  3. These are supported inferences about priorities in these comments, not complete descriptions of either reviewer's personality. Both reviewers may hold several values.

Watch for this mistake: Do not infer a person's whole worldview from a single word. Tie a limited interpretation to the exact evaluative wording and its context.

Try it, then explain

  1. A reviewer praises a playground as ‘a place where children of every ability can join in’. Which value is foregrounded? Cite evidence.

    Hint

    Identify what receives approval.

    Answer and explanation

    Inclusion or accessibility, supported by ‘every ability’ and ‘join in’.

  2. A review calls a building ‘beautifully untouched by fashion’. How could this reveal a value?

    Hint

    Consider what the praise treats as desirable.

    Answer and explanation

    It can suggest valuing enduring design or tradition over changing trends. The adverb ‘beautifully’ makes the approval explicit.